HOMOPHOBIA AND HETEROSEXISM -
WHAT THEY ARE, AND WHO AND HOW THEY HURT - GALE-BC
WHAT THEY ARE
Homophobia is the fear, dislike, hatred, aversion, intolerance, and ignorance of homosexuals and homosexuality. These feelings and beliefs usually irrational, result in acts of discrimination, harassment and often violence.
Heterosexism is the promotion of the superiority of heterosexuality, the assumption that everyone is heterosexual, and the belief that heterosexuality is the only right, correct, normal and moral expression of sexuality.
Although these simplified definitions are useful, it is also important to provide further information as to the different forms of homophobia and heterosexism. It is also important to note that homophobia and heterosexism are learned attitudes and behaviours, and that they can be prevented or unlearned.
Individual or Personal homophobia and heterosexism exist when an individual holds and perpetrates the attitudes and behaviours described above. The individual may be thinking, feeling and acting consciously or unconsciously, deliberately or naively, but the result, nevertheless, usually has negative consequences for lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender (LGBT) people.
Internalized homophobia and heterosexism exist when an LGBT person holds and perpetuates the attitudes, values and beliefs described above. LGBT people, like all members of society, have been subjected to negative conditioning about homosexuality; when we accept these negative beliefs we are exhibiting internalized homophobia or heterosexism. Some examples of the destructive force of internalized fear or self-hatred are: denial of one's sexual orientation, contempt for "out" or obvious LGBT people, distrust of other LGBT people, projection of prejudice onto another minority group, or even directly onto other LGBT people, attempts to pass as heterosexual, sometimes even dating or marrying someone of the opposite sex, increased fear and withdrawal from friends and relatives, and in some instances suicide.
Societal or cultural homophobia and heterosexism exist when the media, (television, film, radio, daily newspapers, popular magazines and books) perpetuate the attitudes and beliefs described above. Until very recently, invisibility, caricature, negative stereotypes, and/or exaggerated, emotionally-laden, hysteria-producing depictions (such as linking homosexuality to pedophilia or promiscuity) have been some of the more prominent features of mainstream media's representations of LGBT people. In addition, many newsworthy events are ignored by the mainstream press, legitimate research in areas such as teen suicide is suppressed, positive role models are seldom portrayed, and the struggle for equality by gays and lesbians is often trivialized as excessive or overindulgent. Although there have been more positive trends recently in some media outlets, many others still fail to present positive, accurate depictions of LGBTs.
Institutional or Systemic homophobia and heterosexism exist in the form of institutional and organizational discrimination against non-heterosexuals by major institutions such as government, schools, churches, courts and corporations. Institutions have tremendous power and social status and (through penalties and rewards, disapproval and approval) create incentives for conformity to their "norms". Again, although there has been some positive change, the majority of institutions continue to actively work against LGBT people. And many of those institutions with anti-discrimination policies on paper, have not yet really managed to create safe, welcoming, inclusive or non-discriminatory environments for LGBT people.
Further examples of institutional/systemic homophobia and heterosexism include the inability to marry, exclusion from contributing to and collecting pensions on behalf of same-sex partners, exclusion from job promotions, invisibility in school curricula, housing discrimination, discrimination with regard to child custody, inability to become ordained in most churches, and discrimination in the military. In many countries, it is illegal to engage in same-sex activity, punishable by death in several.
Heterosexual privilege consists of the benefits and advantages heterosexuals automatically receive in a heterosexist culture. In addition, it includes the benefits lesbians, gay men, and bi-sexual people receive as a result of claiming heterosexual identity or denying their homosexual or bisexual identity.
Heterosexual allies are heterosexual people who actively confront heterosexism, homophobia, and heterosexual privilege in themselves and others out of self-interest, a concern for the well-being of LGBT people, and a belief that homophobia and heterosexism are social justice issues.
Homophobia and Heterosexism in relationship to other forms of oppression.
Homophobia and heterosexism do not exist in isolation and share many characteristics with other forms of prejudice and discrimination such as racism, sexism, anti-Semitism, classism, ageism and ableism. Because of their sexual orientation, lesbians, gays and bisexuals are often denied access to the same rights and privileges enjoyed by others, and are therefore called a "minority" group. Many LGBs are also members of other minority groups and thus suffer oppression in multiple ways.
Suzanne Pharr (1997), elaborates on the common elements of the various oppressions - elements which include all of the following characteristics; a defined norm, a standard of rightness and often righteousness wherein all others are judged in relation to it, and a norm that is backed up with institutional power, economic power, and both institutional and individual violence, and threats of violence.
In addition, those who seek inclusion and rights are defined in relation to the norm as "the Other", and have to struggle for rights because of a lack of prior claim. In addition, the Other's existence, everyday life, and achievements are kept unknown through invisibility, or portrayed negatively through false information and distortion of events. This distortion and lack of knowledge of the Other expresses itself in stereotyping, which results in dehumanization, blaming the victim, internalized oppression (self-hatred which can express itself in depression, despair, and self-abuse), horizontal hostility (disrespect and hatred toward one's own "minority" group or other oppressed peoples), and isolation.
Since the different forms of oppression are connected, coalition building between the affected groups can erode the power and control exercised by the few, and brings about significant positive change. However, those who hold power may oppose such efforts directly through invalidation, minimization and intimidation. They may also set up more subtle ways that block solidarity, through the tactics of assimilation and tokenism, and a promotion and an emphasis on the power of individual solutions, as opposed to systemic change. The challenge is to continue to build coalitions in order to bring about true social justice for all.
Now that we have taken a close look at what homophobia and heterosexism are, it is time to take a closer and more detailed look at the various and specific manifestations of homophobia and heterosexism; who and how they hurt.
HOMOPHOBIA AND HETEROSEXISM: WHO AND HOW THEY HURT
Note: Although the terms homophobia and heterosexism are commonly used when referring to prejudices and discrimination against lesbian, gay and bisexual people, transgender people are also directly and negatively impacted by homophobia and heterosexism. Transphobia is the specific term coined for the fear, hatred, aversion, and intolerance of transgender people. Please read all of the terms below as inclusively as possible. Additionally, as you will come to see, homophobia and heterosexism also impact negatively on heterosexual people and children. In addition, LGBT or "gay" here refer to lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender persons.
There are many specific manifestations of homophobia and heterosexism including:
- Hatred of gays and lesbians -
Many LGBTs live in fear of assault and harassment, because we can be attached for no reason other than for who we are. Our assailants' homophobia often manifests itself via vicious verbal attacks, verbal taunting, physical and emotional intimidation, and physical assault, all of which have been visited upon many LGBT people. Brutal beatings are not uncommon, and hate crimes and murders based on sexual orientation are on the increase. Young people, both actual LGBT youth and those perceived to be LGBT, are particularly vulnerable to hatred within their school communities, as other young people perpetuate most homophobic violence.
- Fear of gays and lesbians - Many people act out their fears of LGBTs in non-violent and commonplace ways. Some people shun their gay neighbours, relatives turn away from their gay family members, co?workers are distantly cold to a gay colleague, young people drop their friend when he/she comes out, parents of school-age children warn their children about gay adults or teachers, parents remove children from an LGBT teacher's classroom, and courts deny custody of children to LGBT parents.
- Fear of being perceived as gay or lesbian - LGBTs are forced to stay in the closet for fear of suffering the violence, prejudices and discrimination described above. "In a third grade classroom there are many times when a hug is just what the child needs. I am very careful not to touch my students, especially the boys, for fear that I will be accused of being gay and lose my job."
Other people are afraid to ask for and to express the physical caring and intimacy felt for one another, for fear of being thought gay or lesbian. Some heterosexual people perceived to be gay are also fearful of the homophobic attitudes and behaviours of others as they too feel unsafe. Additionally, homophobia affects potential allies in that some heterosexual people are reluctant to support or even associate with LGBT people, in case they themselves are thought to be LGBT.
In addition, all youth are affected, heterosexual and non-heterosexual alike. The sex role stereotyping that is often associated with sexual identity, limits those fearful of being perceived as LGBT from pursuing interests and careers that they may otherwise have wished to pursue. Parents sometimes limit the activities of their children based on this same fear.
- Fear of being gay or lesbian - Some people are fearful of their physical or sexual attraction for others of the same gender. "In college I had fantasies about my roommate. To make sure that nothing ever happened, I left early in the morning and came home after he was asleep. We had started out as friends but the friendship fell apart since I was always trying to avoid being together." There is nothing unnatural about being attracted to another person of the same gender. People do not always have to act on these feelings, but nor should they be suppressed or thought of as poisonous. The fear of being gay, lesbian or bisexual has led some LGBT people to deny, suppress and repress their homosexual attractions. This has led some gay and lesbian people into heterosexual marriages which are often unhappy and unsuccessful. Everyone involved suffers when the marriage eventually fails.
The fear of being LGBT has also led some people into so-called "reparative therapy" (touted as a "cure for homosexuality), often after coercion by family or church. Reparative therapy has a long history, although it has been assigned different names throughout the past century. Both psychological and psychiatric professions have soundly denounced "reparative therapy" like many of the past "therapies. Likewise, the recent church-based "reparative therapies" enjoy very little support and credibility. In fact, such "reparative therapies", as well as being non-effective in changing sexual orientation, are likely to cause further trauma and difficulties for most, if not all, LGBT people.
- Invisibility of gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender people, their lives and their contributions- LGBTs exist in every facet of family, workplace, community and political life, leading diverse, well-adjusted, and deeply satisfying lives (in spite of the difficulties created by homophobia and heterosexism). However, this remains a little known reality, especially for most school-age children, who rarely, if ever, see positive or accurate depictions of GLBT people in their schools. In addition, significant current and historical contributions of LGBT people in diverse fields of endeavour are routinely ignored in school curricula. All young people, heterosexual and LGBT, are deprived of the positive role-modelling for diversity that LGBT teachers, counselors, librarians, and administrators could provide if homophobia were absent.
Homophobia prevents all heterosexuals from accepting the benefits and gifts offered by sexual minorities: theoretical insights, social and spiritual visions and options, contributions to the arts and culture, to religion, to family life, indeed to all facets of society. (Blumenfeld, 1992, p.12). This continuing invisibility is a direct result of homophobia and heterosexism, and simultaneously one of the major factors in the continuing perpetuation of homophobia.
Please refer to the books listed below, and to the work of Virginia Uribe in the Los Angeles School District, for further information on the specific manifestations of homophobia and heterosexism.
Blumenfeld, Warren J.; Homophobia: How We All Pay the Price; Beacon Press, 1992
Bohan, Janis S.; Psychology and Sexual Orientation: Coming to Terms; Routledge, 1996
Pharr, Suzanne.; Homophobia: A Weapon of Sexism (Expanded Edition); Chardon Press, 1997.
Uribe, Virginia.; "Project 10"; Los Angeles Unified School District, 1989
Canadian Teachers' Federation policy includes: "Sexuality education should include information and discussion about sexual orientation, homophobia, and discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation."
|